The one person, one vote standard in redistricting. Thomas brunell argued that partisan districts packed with likeminded voters actually lead to better representation than ones more evenly split between democrats and republicans, because fewer voters in partisan districts cast a vote for a losing candidate. Census bureau, according to two people who have been briefed on the bureaus plans. Trump pick to lead 2020 census pulls name from consideration. Ei and there are related software packages that can implement this more complicated method. Pick to help run 2020 census no longer under consideration. Critics recoiled at the news, citing brunell s 2008 book, redistricting and representation. House of representatives that reflects a fair representation of the people of the united states. Public redistricting services should provide the public with the ability to make available all published redistricting plans and community boundaries in nonproprietary formats.
Trumps frightening pick for top census job thinks competitive elections are bad for america. The trump administrations pick for a key position overseeing the 2020 census is out, the commerce department confirmed monday, as civil rights groups applauded the decision. Brunell, the one person, one vote standard in redistricting. It is, generally, a complex, volatile, and highly political.
Why competitive elections are bad for america, and his lack of experience as further evidence that the. Professor brunell is the author of numerous scholarly publications including, among many others. To assist the general assembly with its work in redistricting and reapportionment, the bipartisan legislative task force on redistricting, reapportionment, and demographic research the task force was created by statute in the early 1990s. This includes legislation to refund government programs and the debt. Thomas brunell is a political science professor with no government experience, and would politicize the agency tasked with counting every resident of the u. Thomas brunell is a political science professor with no government experience. Redistricting and representation controversies in electoral democracy and representation. Program head of political science, public policy and political economy. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Brunells redistricting and representation is useful to consider. Election law is a dynamic and quickly growing field that has garnered enormous public interest. The government accountability office now calls it a high risk program. In twoparty competition, it is well known that the party whose supportersidentifiers are more ideologically concentrated can pull the overall median in the direction of its party median, while the overall mean is essentially simply an average of the two party means weighted by the number of supportersidentifiers of each party. The vcrtf found gis redistricting software to be efficient and effective in its ability to move boundary lines according to demographics, such as race and voting age, by district to include.
Gill may lead to a fairer, more democratic redistricting process. Brunell makes the case for a radical departure from traditional approaches to redistricting arguing that we need to pack districts with as many likeminded partisans as possible, maximizing. Amici are well positioned to predict how recent developments in the availability of data on voters, the capabilities of mapmaking software, and the capacities of data. Brunell, a professor at the university of texas at dallas, is a republican who advocates the virtues of noncompetitive elections and testifies on behalf of gop redistricting. Evaluating the impact of redistricting on district homogeneity, political competition, and political extremism in the us house of representatives, 19622002. Blending incisive legal analysis, with insights from social choice theory, mcgann, smith, latner, and keena explain how a largely unnoticed court case has allowed the republican party to violate the fundamental democratic principle of one man one vote to ensure their control of the house of representatives. Thomas brunell laments polarized debate over 2020 census. Thomas brunell was criticized for lacking government experience and. Trumps pick to run the 2020 census helped republicans. The trump administration is leaning toward naming thomas brunell, a texas professor with no government experience, to the top operational job at the u. Why competitive elections are bad for america, a 2008 book for the. On tuesday, politico reported that the trump administration may appoint thomas brunell. Someone who doesnt believe in free and fair elections is going to be head of the agency in. Why competitive elections are bad for america controversies in electoral democracy and representation 1 by brunell, thomas l.
The administration is seriously considering appointing thomas brunell to deputy. Under what circumstances can minorities defeat majorities in american democracy. Project funded by the sloan foundation, money to support development of redistricting software. The north carolina judges point to the contradictory testimony of thomas brunell, a republican expert witness. Apparent white house pick to lead census sparks concern about. This pattern of lying to judges seems to be a pattern among gerrymander defenders. The term was coined by bernard grofman and thomas brunell in their article. A commerce department spokesman said political scientist thomas brunell was no longer under consideration for deputy director of the census bureau but provided no further details.
Brunell, the university of texas, dallas, professor, said it could be related to the declining strength of political parties. If true, it signals an effort by the administration to politicize the census, terri ann lowenthal, former codirector of the census project. The gop has repeatedly used thomas brunell s research in redistricting efforts, and he appeared as an expert witness to defend gopled states in lawsuits over potential gerrymandering. Critics recoiled at the news, citing brunells 2008 book, redistricting and.
In june 2011, the north carolina legislature hired thomas brunell, a professor of political science at the university of texas at dallas, to produce a report that. Why competitive elections are bad for america controversies in electoral democracy and representation kindle edition by brunell, thomas. It is a subject of great practical importance to lawyers and law students, with increasing litigation and several important decisions from the supreme court in recent years. Why competitive elections are bad for america, prof. Voter suppression, redistricting, gerrymandering all tie into the census. Trump is reportedly leaning toward naming thomas brunell, a texas professor and author of redistricting and representation. Abstract scholars of redistricting often make reference to communities of interest, either to describe what districts should look like, or to criticize blatant partisan gerrymanders. Brunell professor of political science school of economic, political and policy sciences the university of texas at dallas 800 w. A community of interest includes, for example, shared history, race, culture, socioeconomic status, and geography. According to politico, trumps potential census pick, thomas brunell, is causing alarm for many across the country. Project funded by the sloan foundation to provide for public redistricting in new york and continued software development. Yet the exact nature of the relationship between the overall.
Defining communities of interest in redistricting through. Thomas brunell, a texas professor with zero government experience, is the trump administrations favorite to be named as deputy secretary at the u. Redistricting, responsiveness, and issue attention. A politicalscience view of trumps reported census pick. Delivered a speech to the league of women voters of broome and tioga counties entitled redistricting after census 2000.
Thomas brunell 2008, in redistricting and representation. In the supreme court of the united states redistricting. An overview introduction every 10 years, through the apportionment and redistricting processes within each state, congress and the states attempt to create a u. Why competitive elections are bad for america routledge 2008. Census bureau, a vital position that will impact the 2020 census as well as forthcoming elections. Thomas brunells work challenges a widely held conviction in his field. Brunell makes the case for a radical departure from traditional approaches to redistricting arguing that we need to pack.
Someone who doesnt believe in free and fair elections is going to be head of the agency in charge of getting a accurate count of how many people are in the country. Plaintiffs, registered voters, filed a complaint seeking to have the redistricting plans declared invalid on both constitutional and statutory grounds. Pdf download election law in a nutshell free ebooks pdf. A politicalscience view of trumps reported census pick the. The controversial possible pick for a top census job citylab. Read redistricting and representation why competitive elections are bad for america by thomas brunell available from rakuten kobo. The second segment of the project will use redistricting software to develop maps that will stand up to legal scrutiny. In june 2011, the north carolina legislature hired thomas brunell, a professor of political science at the university of texas at dallas, to. The gop war on voting page 2 politics and economics. For the past seven years, he has been collecting municipal records of murders, and he now has the largest catalogue of killings in the country751,785 murders carried out since 1976, which is roughly. Elections, business programs, political reform and state archives. Pundits have observed that if so many incumbents are returned to congress to each election by such wide margins, perhaps. I am a professor of political science at the university of texas at dallas, and. In his 2008 book, redistricting and representation.
But it arguably is, which is why the late republican gerrymandering whiz thomas hofeller, who was in touch with trumps transition team, was so keen on the idea of obtaining better citizenship data. The term, however, suffers from a great deal of ambiguity, the lack of an objective measurement strategy, and the absence of a methodology for translating beliefs about communities of interest into. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading redistricting and representation. Alec wilkinson, reporting for the new yorker, profiled thomas hargrove, who is deep into finding serial killers algorithmically and through public data thomas hargrove is a homicide archivist. The communications department oversees all media relations for the california secretary of state s office and keeps the public informed of the latest news from the agencys various divisions.
Commendation for virginia redistricting competition. American political science association, information and technology politics section. Redistricting by a ventura county community task force. Redistricting and representation argues that competition in general elections is not the sine qua non of healthy democracy, and that it in fact contributes to the low levels of approval of congress and its members. Why competitive elections are bad for america controversies in electoral democracy and representation series by thomas brunell. Following the 2010 decennial census, the general assembly enacted redistricting plans for the north carolina senate and house of representatives and for the north carolina districts for the united states house of representatives. Find and follow posts tagged gerrymander on tumblr. The fewer competitive districts we have, the better the federalist. Department of commerce, outlining several deep concerns with the 2020 census on wednesday. In the 1960s and 1970s, primaries took on more importance and the.
Iowa is the redistricting unicorn its a state where the politicians of both parties agreed to take the politics out of redistricting, turned it over to professionals and nonpartisans, and somehow no one. Trumps census pick argued competitive elections are bad. So trumps leading pick for the census bureau is thomas brunell a texas university professor who wrote a book called why competitive elections are bad for america. Redistricting and representation ebook by thomas brunell. Software necessary to replicate the creation or analysis of redistricting plans and community boundaries produced by the service must be publicly available. More than 160 mayors issued a joint letter to wilbur ross, the secretary of the u. Redistricting and representation controversies in electoral democracy and representation brunell, thomas l.
Redistricting and representation by brunell, thomas ebook. And for the census bureaus top operational post, president trump is reportedly considering thomas brunell, a republican defender of gerrymandering who wrote a book entitled redistricting and representation. Redistricting and representation controversies in electoral. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Trumps frightening pick for top census job thinks competitive elections are bad for america leave a reply. The power of ideologically concentrated minorities.
643 248 1119 426 1557 1258 449 1292 2 451 973 704 48 537 623 1442 849 302 319 193 442 1264 39 59 899 525 1163 426 784 392 569 41 653 287 963 164 446 358 299